Most helpful customer reviews
43 of 46 people found the following review helpful.
Multiple viewings and an open mind
By Daniel Barham
There are a lot of reviews for this movie, but having listened to this debate for 3 years I want to put my thoughts down. My first viewing in the theatre I came away going "wow that was intense and a new take on Superman". Then I started reading the criticism and that started changing my mind about what I saw and even debated one of my friends who loved the movie about its faults. Then I watched it again and realized the reviews and myself were wrong. This movie receives a lot hypocritical flack for no reason. I also read a bunch of Superman comics to see where they were coming from in the criticism . Let me say this, there is no definitive Superman only your definitive Superman. If you prefer Reeve that's fine, but there is room for multiple interpretations. People saying Snyder doesn't know the character are wrong as well. Lines and shots are taking from Birthright and John Byrnes Man of Steel. This is a very post 1987 Superman and really resembles more of the stories from the new 52 and early 2000s such as War of the Supermen, For Tomorrow, and Earth One.
This film is a roller-coaster. From the intense opening to the calmer coming of age then the 2 big battles. Once we get the invasion from Zod the movie doesn't slow down. On first viewing that can be alot to take, but again repeat viewings make me enjoy it more. There are shots in this movie that are absolutely gorgeous and breathtaking. The score compliments the movie greatly and even though there is no charging theme Zimmer's more subtle work feels right. There is joy in the film as well, but it's not spoon fed to you. It is subtle like many of the themes in the film. Another aspect of the movie i love is a great villain who believes he is right and will not stop to achieve his goal. Snyder puts Superman in extremely difficult situations and he has to make hard choices. If any other character did what he did at the end of the film no one would blink an eye, but because it's Superman everyone freaks out. However, as I said this villain would not stop and there was no prison to hold him so Supes made the tough choice. You can clearly see the pain it caused him. If you have issues with this movie please see man of steel answers on youtube. I think as more time goes by this movie will get the respect it deserves.
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful.
love to see Clark Kent/Superman struggle from an early age ...
As an adult who grew up watching Superman and the Justice League, I have to say that I can understand why some people have their reservations about this move. I, on the other hand, love to see Clark Kent/Superman struggle from an early age with the fact that he is an "other." This is SO relatable now a days when so many people feel like they don't belong or are an outcast. We see him struggle with his powers and identity and spending a lifetime looking for answers.
After his adoptive father's death (and finding out about his origin), we see him believe that the world is not ready. The movie portrays a human side to him and a ideological pathos from a young boy to eventually superhero when the planet he grew up is under eminent danger. Overall, this movie is a five star in my book. The fight scenes are believable and not too over the top. This, however, is my personal opinion. You may dissent.
0 of 0 people found the following review helpful. See all 5585 customer reviews...
A View From Before The DC Shared Universe Concept Ruined Everything It Touched
By Jason Ilgenfritz
A solid re-imagining of a modern American folk tale.
Zak Snyder's visual instincts are strong. He pulls heavily from the decades of ample source material. Henry Cavill presents a strong Superman, a stronger Clark Kent, and the performances by Diane Keaton and Kevin Costner as the Kents are some of the best of the career.
Far superior to the droll Batman V. Superman and Suicide Squad movies of later years, this original foray into the DC canon - with the inimitable Michael Shannon seeming an almost worthy successor to Terence Stamp's Zod and Russell Crowe turning in a performance as Jor-El that in no way steals from the iconic performance of Brando - seemed full of promise and brought back childhood memories of discovering for the first time that a man could fly.
The Blu-Ray/DVD/DigiDownload Combo was definitely the right choice, offering the best of all viewing opportunities. Substantial extra features - common for most of Snyder's earlier outings as well - round things out nicely.